The role of LEAD is undergoing a sea change like many
of the NGOs in India. NGOs involved in economic programmes
are increasingly playing the role of a financial intermediary,
directly lending to groups and individuals. So far LEAD
has been predominantly facilitating financial linkage
of groups with the banks. Keeping in view the credit
requirements of the members and the need to diversify
the source funds for the groups, LEAD is slowly turning
itself into a MFI.
LEAD is borrowing from Rashtriya Mahila Khosh, Small
Industries Development Bank of India (SIDBI), Rabo Bank
and other agencies for lending to the groups. The transformation
process from a mere developmental organisation to a
Micro Financial Institution is full of challenges and
dilemmas. The NGO in this phase is neither a development
agent nor a full-fledged financial institution.
The characteristics of the organisation right from
the goals of the organisation, the staff capacity building
and orientation, client population, sources of funding,
methodology of lending operations, financial management
and management information system need reorientation
to face the changing requirements.
The important change requirement in transformation
relates to the manner in which information on the NGO's
operations is generated, consolidated, analyzed and
reviewed. From a mere reporting of activities in terms
of programmes and expenses incurred, an aspiring MFI
has to generate information on financial quantities,
costs, returns, portfolio quality, repayment rates and
the like. Unlike pure development work, MFI work leads
to financial assets, which need to be accounted for
over a period of time, with regular computation of profit
and loss arising out of the transactions. Design of
an effective MIS is a key issue in a nascent MFI.
a. New challenges
When the organisation turns into a financial intermediary
the information required becomes multifarious. This
is due to the following factors:
Need to cover costs - The expenses of the developmental
organisation are met out of grants and donations. A
financial intermediary needs to cover costs and make
profits to become sustainable in the long run. Thus
MIS is in the process of being modified to generate
information on the expenditure incurred and income generated
out of lending operations in order to monitor whether
the organisation is moving towards self-sufficiency.
Expansion of operations - Many organisations expand
their operations to include new areas of work and new
clients. The information system needs to give data about
how well the organisation is doing in the new areas.
Client population and needs - A financial intermediary
needs to address the financial requirements of the clientele
and fine tune its methodology and loan terms to satisfy
their requirements. A MFI may start with group lending
initially with a single loan product. With the passage
of time and expansion of operations different loan products
need to be developed and introduced. MIS should provide
useful information about the success and problems in
the expansion of business and the variety in loan products.
Loan portfolio quality - There is a need to measure
the health of the loan portfolio. The test of the success
of the lending institution is to effect very good repayments.
Over and above the data on outstanding loans and repayments
collected it is necessary to segregate the amounts prepaid
and repayments due and collected to arrive at actual
repayment rates. It is necessary to carryout age wise
classification of loans in default so that effective
monitoring can be undertaken. The organisation can also
frame effective policies for loan write off based on
the data collected.
Efficiency of staff - The staff is the most productive
asset of the MFI. Similarly the salary costs form the
major expense of the MFI. The staff efficiency needs
to be monitored in terms of number of clients they cater
to and the loan portfolio they handle.
Regulatory framework - Unlike a NGO the micro financial
institution's activities are likely to be regulated
especially if the organisation is mobilising the savings
of the public. The MIS should take care of the reporting
needs of the organisation.
b. Changes in MIS
LEAD has broadly identified the information requirements
and changes are being made in the following categories
of information:
Progress reports on savings, loans, and other micro
financial services such as insurance and quality of
loan portfolio.
Financial statements for the MFI - income and expenditure
and balance sheet for the MFI operations.
Customer information - Group performance details, Loan
tracking of the clients, customer satisfaction for the
financial services and impact assessments.
Progress reports - portfolio information
LEAD's repoting sysytem has undergone changes in the
recent past. Field offices till now collected and monitored
data on the sanction of loans under various individual
loans such as housing, toilet construction and Milch
animals loans. However, it plans to collect some more
detailed information regarding different type of loans
being sanctioned by the organisation. Now such information
is collected on a monthly basis and consolidated at
the project level. Instead of figures of loans disbursed,
collected and outstanding some more refinement is being
implemented . The loans prepaid are being segregated
to arrive at actual on time repayments. Similarly the
loans outstanding and overdue are being categorised
into five categories.
Outstanding for more than 30 days.
,, ,, 31 to 60 days.
,, ,, 61 to 90 days.
,, ,, 91 to 180 days.
,, ,, 180 days and above.
Such categorisation has helped the organisation to assess
the quality of loans and also to take effective follow
up measures to ensure repayment. Though LEAD has not
experienced any loan loss due to defaults, this exercise
has helped in framing a policy for setting up a reserve
for loan loss, as any prudent financial organisation
should do.
LEAD has recently introduced the insurance scheme for
cattle and goats. It is proposed to centralise data
collection on the insurance premia collected and claims
settled.
Financial statements - At present the financial operations
of the organisation are reflected in the audited annual
reports. The information pertains the data all the operations
of the organisation and hence separate analysis of the
micro credit operations are difficult to be made. Thus
it is necessary to segregate the data for financial
and non-financial operations separately so that the
sustainability of the MFI operations can be tracked.
LEAD is undertaking an exercise to allocate the income
and expenses for the financial and non-financial services.
Segregating the income is relatively an easy exercise.
Similarly the balance sheets are also being segregated
for financial and non-financial services. Though the
exercise is time taking and difficult LEAD finds that
this would benefit the organisation in the long run
in monitoring the sustainability of operations and taking
necessary decisions to move the financial operations
towards sustainability. Moreover, such financial statements
are required for further fund raising since any donor
or financing agency would like to satisfy them that
the organisation is moving towards self-sustainability.
c. The next step - computerisation
Once the scope of work and the type of data to be generated
are determined the next issue to be addressed are staff
capacity, computerisation requirements and cost considerations.
These three issues need to be addressed together. Computerisation
is expensive and the capacity of the staff to manage
computers is an important ingredient to the successful
computer based MIS.
LEAD has computerised major portion of its operation
in the Head office level . The field offices are not
yet computerised. Given the advances in computer technology,
the increasing scale of micro finance intermediation
and the importance of developing efficient low cost
product delivery LEAD finds that some amount of computerisation
is necessary for its information needs. In this regard
LEAD has planned to purchase software developed exclusively
for monitoring its micro finance activities, appropriate
to its facilitation model.